↑↓ to move ↵ to open Esc to close Browse all tools

Money guide

Term vs Whole Life Insurance: The Differences That Matter

Life insurance comes in two families. Term insurance covers you for a set number of years and pays only if you die within them. Cash value insurance, whole life and universal life, is designed to last for life and builds a cash value along the way. The differences show up in how premiums work, what you get back if you stop, and what can go wrong. Here they are as state insurance regulators describe them.

What each type is

The NAIC, the association of state insurance regulators, describes life insurance as a death benefit paid if you die while the policy is in force, in exchange for the premiums you pay. Its buyer's guide sorts policies by a few questions: how long the coverage lasts, how premiums are paid, and whether the policy builds cash value.

  • Term insurance is intended to provide lower-cost coverage for a specific period. Most term policies build no cash value. The California Department of Insurance describes it as a death benefit with no savings element: if you outlive the term, nothing is paid.
  • Whole life insurance is designed to last your entire life. Premiums are set on a schedule meant to stay level, so in the early years they exceed the actual cost of protection, and the excess builds a reserve, the cash value, that helps pay for the policy later.
  • Universal life insurance is also cash value insurance, but with flexible premiums. Premiums and interest are credited to a fund, and charges for expenses and the cost of insurance are taken out of it. You can pay more, less or skip payments, as long as enough remains to keep the policy in force.
  • Variable life ties the cash value to investments you choose, such as stock and bond funds. The NAIC says these policies have the greatest potential to build cash value and the greatest risk of losing it.

Side by side

TermWhole lifeUniversal life
How long it coversA set period, the termYour whole lifetimeLong term, while enough is paid to keep it in force
PremiumsLower to start; higher if you renewPaid on a set schedule, designed to stay levelFlexible, as long as enough is paid to keep it in force
Cash valueUsually noneBuilds from premiums above the cost of coverA fund credited with premiums and interest, minus charges
If you stop payingCoverage lapses with nothing paidCash value can be used under the nonforfeiture optionsCharges are still taken from the cash value
Main riskOutliving the term, or renewing at a higher priceSurrender charges if you cancel earlyPaying too little to keep the policy in force

No prices appear here on purpose: premiums depend on age, health, the amount and the insurer, and the only reliable comparison is between written quotes for the same coverage amount. The NAIC suggests asking for an illustration, a projection of future values and benefits, for any cash value policy.

Term details: renewing and converting

Most term coverage can be renewed at the end of the term even if your health has changed, the NAIC says, but the new premiums are higher. Ask what the renewal premiums will be and whether the right to renew ends at a certain age. A nonrenewable policy simply ends, and continuing coverage means applying for a new one. Some term policies are convertible: the California Department of Insurance describes them as changeable into cash value insurance up to a specified age without a medical exam, at a premium that is likely to be higher.

Cash value details: loans, surrender and lapse

  • Cash value builds unevenly. In some policies the values are low in the early years and build later; in others they grow gradually, the NAIC notes.
  • Policy loans. The cash value can secure a loan at the rate set in the policy. Any loan still outstanding is deducted from what is paid at death or on surrender.
  • Surrender charges. Cancelling early usually costs a fee, typically within roughly the first seven or eight years, according to the California Department of Insurance, which warns against buying cash value coverage if you expect to surrender early.
  • Taxes. A surrender or lapse may create a taxable event; the California guide says to check with a tax advisor.
  • Premiums can rise. The NAIC warns that premiums for many policies are sensitive to the insurer's investment earnings, claims and expenses. Ask for the highest premium you might have to pay to keep the coverage.

How much coverage: a worksheet

The NAIC frames the amount around the financial needs that continue after a death: income for the family, education, a mortgage, debts and final expenses, minus what already exists. It also notes that employer coverage is usually less than you need and may not go with you if you leave. Here is the arithmetic for a hypothetical household; every figure is that household's own estimate, not a recommendation.

ItemAmount
Replace income: $45,000 a year for 10 years$450,000
Pay off the mortgage$240,000
Pay off other debts$12,000
Children's education fund$40,000
Final expenses$15,000
Total needs$757,000
Minus: Savings and investments−$35,000
Minus: Existing coverage through an employer−$90,000
Coverage gap$632,000

The net worth calculator gives the savings and debt figures to start from. The savings goal calculator and the compound interest calculator show how savings grow over the same years, which helps when weighing a policy's projected cash value against money saved elsewhere. Insurance products tied to retirement income are covered in annuities explained.

Questions to ask an agent

  1. Is this term, whole, universal or variable life, and how long does the coverage last?
  2. Which premiums and values are guaranteed, and which are not?
  3. For term: is it renewable or convertible, until what age, and what would the renewal premium be?
  4. For cash value: how is the cash value calculated, and what would I receive if I surrendered in year 1, 5 or 10?
  5. What are the surrender charges, and for how many years do they apply?
  6. What is the highest premium I could be asked to pay to keep the coverage?
  7. If this replaces a policy I already have, what do I lose, and could the contestable period start again? The NAIC says not to cancel a current policy until the new one is in place.
  8. Are the agent and the insurer licensed in my state?

After the policy arrives, use the free look period: the NAIC says you can usually return it for a full refund within about 10 days, and the period is stated on the first page. Review the policy and the beneficiaries every few years and after major life events.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between term and whole life insurance?

Term insurance covers a set period and pays only if you die within it; the NAIC says most term policies build no cash value. Whole life is designed to cover your entire life, with premiums paid on a set schedule, and part of those premiums builds a cash value. Term is intended as lower-cost coverage for a specific period.

Is universal life the same as whole life?

Both are cash value insurance, but the NAIC says the key difference is how you pay. Whole life premiums follow a set schedule, while universal life lets you choose a flexible pattern as long as you pay enough to keep the policy in force. The California Department of Insurance explains that universal life credits premiums and interest to a fund and takes charges for expenses and the cost of insurance out of it.

What is a surrender charge?

A fee for cancelling a cash value policy and taking out its value. The California Department of Insurance says such a charge usually applies if you surrender within roughly the first seven or eight years, which is why it warns against buying cash value insurance if you expect to surrender early. The policy's own schedule gives the actual amounts.

Can I cancel a new life insurance policy?

Yes, during the free look period. The NAIC says you can usually return a new policy for a full refund within about 10 days of receiving it, with the period stated on the first page. California requires 10 to 30 days for individual life policies, at least 30 days for seniors, and 30 days for a replacement policy.

Can term insurance be converted to whole life?

Some term policies can. The California Department of Insurance describes convertible term as coverage that can be changed to cash value insurance up to a specified age without a medical exam, usually at a higher premium. Ask whether a policy is convertible, until what age, and into which products.

Sources

General information based on the sources above, not tax, legal or financial advice.